From Mindless Spending to Mindful Consumption

by Marelisa · View Comments

mindful consumptionJohn Gerzema–who guides the brand strategies for companies such as McDonald’s, Coca Cola, and BMW–gave a Ted.com talk on thoughtful spending which he begins by announcing that thirteen trillion dollars in wealth evaporated during 2008 and 2009. Then he adds that something positive can come out of this.

Before the current financial crisis, we binged.  We super sized our meals, spent lavishly on goods and services we didn’t really need in order to impress our neighbors, succumbed to pressure from marketers to upgrade our tech gadgets on a yearly basis, and so on and so forth.

The personal debt to income ratio in the US went from 65% to 135% in the span of about fifteen years.  Gerzema argues that the consumer drove us headlong into the crisis we face today.

However, since the crisis began, savings have gone up.  Spending has dropped to its lowest level in over sixty years.  Visa reported that more people are using debit cards instead of using credit cards.  That is, we’re paying for things with money that we have instead of going further into debt.  We’re also being much more careful with our savings and how we invest.

Overall, we’re moving from mindless consumption, to mindful consumption.  People are moving toward aligning their values with their spending, and driving businesses to not just be about more, but to be about better.

Gerzema identifies four major cultural shifts driving new consumer behavior, and discusses how businesses are evolving to meet new consumer demands.  These four major shifts are the following:

  • Tendency toward a liquid life.
  • Move toward ethics and fair play.
  • Durable living.
  • Returning to the fold.

Each of these four major shifts is discussed below.

Tendency Toward a Liquid Life

Success is no longer about having things, but about having liquidity.  The less excess that you have around you, the more nimble footed you are. People don’t want to be locked into fixed costs.

In addition, déclassé consumption is in, which means that spending money frivolously makes you look anti-fashion.  Pretense is out; it is now stylish to exercise restraint.

Move Toward Ethics and Fair Play

People are paying attention to a company’s culture and at their conduct in the market place. One example of a company looking to do good is Microsoft: given the high level of unemployment that the US is currently facing, they pledged to give free training in computer technologies to over two million Americans.

Transparency is also something that the marketplace is valuing more and more.  The high-tech materials company W.L. Gore & Associates–which has a very egalitarian workforce philosophy–places their executives’ expense reports on their company web site so that everyone in the company can see them.

Patagonia clothing company is a designer of outdoor clothing and gear. Their mission is to make the best products and cause no unnecessary harm.  Every day they do something to lessen their ecological footprint, and they keep something called The Footprint Chronicles which allows the consumer to track the impact of a specific Patagonia product from design to delivery.

Emphasis on Durable Living

Consumers are looking for ways to extract value out of every purchase that they make.  For example, people are holding on to their cars longer than ever before. Also, there’s an emphasis on both clothing and shoe repair.

This isn’t in Gerzema’s Ted.com talk, but the artist and designer Alexander Rose indicates that just as there is an emphasis today on the slow movement, there is also an emphasis on long-term thinking. He adds that this has given him a fresh view on product design, and the planned obsolescence in consumer products today. Rose says the following:

“I see more clearly how little need there is for all the consumption and waste. I like what [the inventor] Saul Griffith once said. Everyone should receive a Montblanc pen and Rolex watch at birth, and then they’d never need to replace them in a lifetime.” (Source).

There is also a movement toward being sustainable and being able to take care of yourself.  This can be seen in the fact that more and more people are growing their own vegetables, and even keeping their own chickens.

Returning to the Fold

Recently there’s been a rise in community-mindedness.  For one thing, people are looking more and more to their neighbors as their support system. Also, co-operative consumerism has taken off: consumers work together to get what they want out of the marketplace.  They pool their resources to incentivize companies to do good.

The artisanal movement is on the rise.  People look for locally derived products and services, and they support their neighborhood businesses.

There’s also a rise in local currencies.  Communities are printing their own money hoping to help residents make ends meet, as well as helping local businesses that have seen their sales drop due to the recession.

Generally it works as follows: individuals and businesses form a network to print currency. Shoppers buy it at a discount — it could be 90 cents for $1 value — and they spend the full value at stores that accept the currency. Consumers benefit because they get a discount on what they purchase, and the local businesses benefit from increased patronage.  (Source)

Some communities in the United States have started to publish residents’ electricity usage.  As a result, electricity usage in those communities has dropped.

In addition, Time Magazine wrote a few months back about a phenomenon called “cow-pooling”.  This is basically for people who want naturally-raised meat, but who can’t afford natural-food-store prices.  Friends and families band together to buy inexpensive, grass-fed meat directly from farmers.

Conclusion

In 1981 Duane Elgin wrote a book called “Voluntary Simplicity”. It was basically the Bible for those who were tired of working longer and harder, enjoying life less, and missing out on spending quality time with their family and friends, with very little to show for it, other than a mountain of perishable consumer products.

Today there’s a renewed emphasis on simplifying, not just because of the state of the economy, but because people want to live their lives around what really matters to them and, to quote Elgin, live “in a way that is outwardly simple and inwardly rich.”

Gerzema concludes his talk by indicating that values-driven spending will force capitalism to be better, it will drive innovation, and it will make longer lasting products.  This is a hopeful picture for our future.

Here’s John Gerzema’s Ted.com talk:

(Image from here).

Related Posts

Recommended:

How to Be More CreativeMy ebook “How to Be More Creative – A Handbook for Alchemists” explains that creativity is not the sole domain of the arts but is important in any field, from medicine to business, and from engineering to developing a creative solution to a negotiation impasse. Whatever you do, creativity helps you do it better. Discover practical advice on how to be more creative in every life endeavor by reading my ebook.

Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe for free by RSS or e-mail and you’ll always know when I publish something new. (What’s RSS?).

Also, please share it on the social media site of your choice, thank you. :-)

Share and Enjoy:
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • email
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Mixx
  • Reddit
  • Print
  • Netvouz
  • Sphinn
  • Furl
  • dcgikandi
    This is a most welcome change, if you ask me. In a way, I am glad the financial crisis came about. The three things I most like about it is the inherent liberty and lightness of being found in aligning values with spending (less clatter and baggage, more value and meaning), liquidity in life (less pressure to get into debt is always a breath of fresh air), and returning to the fold (people matter, and knowing and living that is more satisfying than a Ferrari, and often, can be more fun).
  • zz
    Hi Marelisa,

    I like this quote in particular:
    "The less excess that you have around you, the more nimble footed you are."

    I love the idea simplifying and keeping yourself light. But I've found that it takes real discipline to practice this! Particularly when you get distracted by pretty colours and enjoy collecting oddities for a rainy day, as I am and do.

    I think more people are definately aware of the excess in their lives, I know I certainly am, and it's great to see that so many people are making a real effect to cool down their consumption. Hopefully it lasts regardless of what happens with the economy next!
  • I love that you said "community mindedness" because we have to think past our own wants and needs to be truly happy.

    I love how active people have become in Haiti. Most of the people that I've worked with have donated. They stopped worrying about their own bank account and gave freely.
  • amitsodha
    Hi Marelisa,

    Superbly informative post. it reminds me of a lot of Martin Lewis too, the guy who started moneysavingexpert.com and got people into the habit of finding savings in everyday life. I love the ethos of WL Gore and A's as it kind of has an alchemy that would be well applied to MP's and expenses and providing accountability. The move towards ethics and fair play is something I'm definitely keen on.
  • Hi Marelisa! I loved Elgin's book THEN and I love it still! I'm forever paring down what I need and use - and it gets more intense as we near the downsizing to retirement. So glad I have two kids to give stuff to! But another level of this is the food we eat - keeping it simple has thinned us both down and we rarely eat out anymore.
  • Very interesting post - I can only hope, like vered, that these are not just direct tied to not having as much money, or at least to the fear of not having more money. If they are simplifying because of fear, when the fear goes away, what happens?

    I think that if we can change from mindless to mindful LIVING, internally, that's when the external change in all areas will be long-lasting and widespread.
  • I really enjoyed watching the video! Interesting information presented here. It's great that the trend is shifting towards greater consciousness! Thumbs up!
  • Marelisa
    Hi Evelyn: I agree that these are positive trends, and I certainly hope that capitalism and consumer behavior continue to move along those lines.
  • Hi Marelisa -- now I feel like I've absorbed the entire talk within two minutes or less of reading! I would totally buy your Cliffs Notes if you wrote them -- perhaps there is a side venture waiting in the wings.
  • Marelisa
    Hi Chris: Thank you. When I was in school everyone wanted to study with me because I created the best summaries of the reading material. :-)
  • bridgetpilloud
    In the next 7 years, my sweetheart and I are jettisoning all of our stuff and downsizing to a sailboat. Every time I go shopping, I think, "Will that fit in our sailboat?"
    If not, "Will I get 7 years of good use out of it?"

    Liquidity in time and resources is a big damn deal, and I am really happy that we're all thinking about it!
  • Marelisa
    Hi Bridget: A sailboat, that sounds exciting! I agree, it's important to keep your liquidity.
  • I agree with every single word but have to wonder - will this be short lived and forgotten once the recession is over, or how we witnessing true change.
  • Marelisa
    Hi Vered: I read an article that indicated that kids are very much shaped by the economy they live through as children. Maybe todays' kids will grow up with this mentality of mindful consumption.
  • Nearly all of my friends and family are on unemployment and have been for the past year. Sadly, their unemployment is going to be expiring in a few weeks. What if they don't find a job? That's a scary thought...

    Other than the fact that unemployment in my state is skyrocketing. I have not seen any relative negative effects to my local city. This city is still booming, just as much as always.
  • Marelisa
    Hi Travis: That is a scary thought. I know there are a lot of people who have started their own business as a way of creating a job for themselves.
  • I know so many people who got in debt just by trying to 'keep up with the Jones'. Instead of living within their means, they were living within someone else's. I do see this trend changing though and it does make me hopeful for a better economic future in our country.

    I love the local currency trend. As a country, we do need to support our small to medium businesses - the backbone of our economy.

    Great article!
  • Marelisa
    Hi Heather: I love the concept of déclassé consumption. Now it's uncool to purchase things you don't really need. :-)
  • mindfulmimi
    Marelisa,
    Very to the point. When I was a kid we had a little shop in our village. I was sad to see it close: they had the best candy. But it could not survive facing the giant supermarket that had everything better and cheaper. Now I see a reverse trend sneaking in. People buy more mindfully, locally. So maybe one of these days the small shops in the villages return.
    M
  • Marelisa
    Hi Mimi: Your comment made me think of the movie "You've Got Mail" with Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks. She had a little "corner" book store and she went out of business because he opened a department store with a huge book section just a block away.
  • I think the crisis forces people to revaluate what they really want and need. It's unfortunate that we had to wait such a drastic event to realize it, but that's how it works.
  • Marelisa
    Hi Oscar: A lot of the time we don't examine our lives and where we're headed unless some outside event forces us to. You're right, that's often how it works.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: