What would you do in order to make as much money as possible if you were given five dollars and two hours?
This is an assignment which Tina Seelig–the Stanford Technology Ventures Program’s Executive Director–often gives to her students.
I came across a lecture on “The Art of Teaching Entrepreneurship and Innovation” given by Seelig at Stanford in May of this year, which is based on her book, What I Wish I Knew When I Was 20: A Crash Course on Making Your Place in the World. The lecture–which you can watch here–contains a lot of great insights on creative thinking and how to develop an entrepreneur mindset.
Below you’ll find some of the pearls of wisdom which Seelig shares in her talk.
Five Dollars and Two Hours
Seelig explains that when she’s teaching classes on entrepreneurship she often asks her students to form teams, and she gives each team an envelope which she tells them contains “seed funding”. There are five dollars in the envelope, but the students have no idea how much seed money is contained in the sealed envelope.
They’re given from Wednesday afternoon until Sunday evening, and are told that they can use as much of that time as they want to come up with a money-making plan. However, once they open the envelope, they have two hours to generate as much money as possible. The students are encouraged to do the following:
- Identify opportunities.
- Challenge assumptions.
- Leverage their limited resources (time and money).
- Be creative.
On Sunday evening each team has to send Seelig a slide telling her what they did. Then, on Monday, each team has three minutes to present their project to the class.
What are some of the ideas people typically come up with when presented with a challenge of this sort? They usually say they would use the seed money to purchase start up materials for a lemonade stand or a car wash. This is fine if you want to make just a few dollars in the two hours. But if you want to create as much value as possible in those two hours you have to seriously challenge traditional assumptions.
In fact, Seelig explains that the teams that make the most money don’t use the five dollars at all. They realize that focusing on the money frames the problem too tightly: asking “What can I do with five dollars?” is too limiting.
Instead, they ask: “What can I do to make money in two hours if all I have are my observation skills–the ability to observe problems others are having–and my talents?” The winning teams typically bring in over $600 after asking themselves this question.
For example, one team identified a problem that is quite common in college towns: the long lines at popular restaurants on Saturday night. The team booked reservations at several restaurants; then, as the times for their reservations approached, they sold the reservations for up to twenty dollars to people who were happy not to have to wait in line.
Another team set up a stand in front of the student union where they offered to measure bicycle tire pressure for free. If the tires needed filling they would add air for a dollar. When they realized how appreciative people were of this service they decided to stop charging a dollar and ask for donations instead. What they found is that most people donated more than a dollar. Experimenting along the way, and adjusting their strategy accordingly, paid off!
The team that made the most money looked at their resources from a completely different lens. These students concluded that their most precious resource were the three minutes they were going to be given on Monday to give their presentation to the class.
They sold the three minutes to a company that wanted to recruit the students in the class. The team created a three minute “commercial” for the company and showed it to the students during their presentation time.
Here’s a six-minute clip in which Seelig talks about this assignment:
Some of the lessons to be learned from this are the following:
- We often limit ourselves unnecessarily. What self-imposed limitations are holding you back?
- Question your assumptions.
- Opportunities lie in solving problems for others. Seelig often tells her students that the bigger the problem, the bigger the opportunity.
- Look at the world as opportunity rich.
- Be willing to go outside of your comfort zone. You have to be willing to take risks and do things you haven’t done before.
- Planning is important, but you have to get out there and test your theories. Take corrective action as needed.
What would you have done if you had been given this assignment?
Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe for free by RSS or e-mail and you’ll always know when I publish something new. (What’s RSS?). Also, please share it on the social media site of your choice.
Related Posts
- Zen Capitalism: Randy Komisar
- The World Needs Alchemists: Creative Capitalism
- Creativity Insights From Seth Godin
- Use Creativity to Double Your Way to a Million Dollars
I Recommend:
My ebook “How to Be More Creative – A Handbook for Alchemists” explains that creativity is not the sole domain of the arts but is important in any field. Whatever you do, creativity helps you do it better. Discover practical advice on how to be more creative in every life endeavor by reading my ebook.
The Sedona Method is a simple, powerful, easy-to-learn technique that shows you how to let go of any negative, unwanted or painful feelings you may be experiencing at any particular moment. It consists of a series of questions you ask yourself that lead your awareness to focus on what you’re feeling in the moment and gently guide you toward letting it go. Read my review of the Sedona Method here.










RSS
Twitter
{ 28 comments }
Great post. I love the creativity the students expressed.
Hi Mare,
I saw this recently, and was really drawn in to the ideas that some of the students came up with – for me, I was especially taken in to the idea of the assumptions we too often make – and by removing those assumptions, how this can really open up possibilities. I love the creativity that was used!
Me too. You can literally make money out of nothing if you provide value for others.
Hi Lance: Tina Seelig looks like one of those teachers that really gets through to their students. I hope that not too many people had already seen it.
Thanks for sharing this it was a fantastic example of creative thinking. I love articles like these because they expand my thinking which expands my world.
Keep them coming.
Hi Deborah: I thought it was a fantastic example of creative thinking as well. As soon as I saw it I thought “I have to blog about this”. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Hi Mare, I had seen it before somewhere, but seeing it again was great!
Fantastic post Marelisa – sometimes the creativity of other people blows your mind – and makes you think about how you can blow apart limitations in your own life!
There are too many limitations we put on ourselves. I know I limit myself in many areas of my life. It's my fear. It's always my fear.
It's overcoming our fear of failure that will allow us to see the limitless possibilities out there.
This isn't easy. I know. I've been trying for many years. The more I experiment and test the stronger I get. Each month I feel less limited. Thanks for a great post. Needed this encouragement.
Hi Karl: We do limit ourselves in far too many ways. And you're right: mostly it's about fear. I'm getting a lot better at getting over my fears too.
Hi Ami: I saw you shared this on your blog too.
I think everyone should be exposed to this kind of creative thinking.
Hi Charles: I guess the video kind of went viral.
Hi Marelisa – This is interesting. I hadn't heard it before. But I did recently learn of an experiment where people were given a sum of money to do with as they pleased, and those that gave away the money had a much greater sense of satisfaction than those who spent it. So when I first read your headline, that's where my thoughts immediately went: I would use the time to look back at my previous year in business, identify one or two clients or former clients who had referred the most new clients to me, then send each a small gift certificate, perhaps for coffee, along with a note of thanks and gratitude. Although it might not produce immediate monetary gain, the intrinsic reward would be great, and I do believe it would lead to more business in the future. And if I had more time to work on it, I'd send individual notes of thanks to all previous clients (and forget about the $5 entirely).
“We often limit ourselves unnecessarily” – so true. My first thought when I read the title was “that's impossible!”
This was a terrific post! What limits us the most often has to do with the limitations we place on ourselves. Thanks for sharing this article and video!
Wow! What an ingenious, hands-on assignment! Thanks for writing about this, and reminding us that how we frame challenges can really limit (or “unlimit) our opportunities.
Hi Patty: I love your comment. And it's interesting because Tina Seelig explains that in other classes she started giving students objects like post-it notes and asking them to create as much “value” as they could with the post-it notes, however they chose to define value. Creating goodwill with your clients is certainly creating value.
Aha! Oh ye of little faith.
We do need to identify our mental limitations and release them.
Hi Cheryl: I think we also need to get over our lineal thinking: first I buy raw materials, then I turn them into a product and sell it, then with the profits I buy more raw materials, and so on. There are ways to create value that are much faster and efficient.
Hi Miche: Exactly; how you frame the problem is incredibly important.
Hi Marelisa .. great post – my brain is stuck in ?? It's Christmas – how can we think now??!!
No – really interesting answer and really opening up the lateral thinking .. I do think laterally (I think!) .. but that flumoxed me – perhaps because I'll never be in that position as such .. other things I always find a way round .. and I'm always looking for ideas and opportunities ..
Don't sell too much lemonade this week! – you'd be out there selling the recipe!
Hilary Melton-Butcher
Positive Letters Inspirational Stories
Great stuff, Marelisa; how the heck do you find these things? This is truly thinking outside the box; I need to work on applying this type of thinking to my businesses.
Hi Hillary: I know what you mean about finding the way around things, I do this too. Especially when there's a looming deadline.
Hi Mitch: Thank you. Actually, I think these things kind of find me.
I found this video in particular because I always go over the last few Tweets of new people who start following me, and I saw a reference to this video in a Tweet from a new follower. I followed the link, watched the video, loved it, and decided to write about it.
Great post! I'll be back to read more.
P.S. Thinking about this more I came to realize that those who were most successful with this project reminded me very much of Bert in Mary Poppins. On a gorgeous day he does sidewalk art, on another day he plays music and yet another he sweeps chimneys – always utilizing his talents to the best of his ability at the right moment. Sounds like a recipe for success if we identify our talents and the moments in which to offer them.
Great post! I'll be back to read more.
P.S. Thinking about this more I came to realize that those who were most successful with this project reminded me very much of Bert in Mary Poppins. On a gorgeous day he does sidewalk art, on another day he plays music and yet another he sweeps chimneys – always utilizing his talents to the best of his ability at the right moment. Sounds like a recipe for success if we identify our talents and the moments in which to offer them.
{ 3 trackbacks }