Suppose you have what you consider to be a great idea for a product, but you don’t have the time, the money, or the know-how to turn your idea into reality. There may now be a solution for your problem.
Serial entrepreneur Ben Kaufman–who created mophie and kluster–has just launched a new enterprise called Quirky, Inc. Leena Rao from “TechCrunch” called it “social networking for product development.”
So, how does it work? Basically, you submit your idea–along with $99–and you get feedback from the Quirky community, a chance to be chosen from among the other ideas submitted that week for prototyping, and the possibility that your idea will make it to the marketplace.
Quirky’s business model is very interesting, and if you have an idea bouncing around in your head which you would like to see developed, or if you’re just interested in discovering how a product goes from being an idea in someone’s head to sitting on a shelf at Walmart, read the explanation below.
The Quirky Process
Here, in a nutshell, is the process they use at Quirky to develop a new product every few days, based on ideas submitted by the community.
One. You visit the Quirky, Inc. web site and submit your idea, along with $99.00. Kaufman explains that there’s a submission fee to make sure that people only submit those ideas which they think have a real possibility of being viable. Submissions must be non-electronic consumer products that can be retailed under $150.00.
Two. The Quirky community–that is, anyone who creates an account for free at Quirky–offers feedback on your idea in the form of comments. They offer their opinion in terms of the viability of your idea, whether it’s something they would be interesting in buying, if they’ve already seen a product similar to what you’re proposing being sold somewhere else, and so on. They also propose ways in which you could improve upon your idea.
Three. Members of the Quirky community decide which ideas to vote for among all of the ideas submitted in any one particular week. The idea that gets the most votes is the winner for the week.
Four. Quirky, Inc. has a team of professionals that will get to work on creating a prototype of the product that won for the week. During the development of the prototype, the Quirky community gets to weigh in on every step of the process: your product’s design, name, packaging, color scheme, and so on. Keep in mind that if your product is chosen you lose all rights to the product. However, you don’t have to pay anything to have the product developed, and you do get compensated, as is explained further down below.
Five. Based on your product’s price point, Quirky will determine how many units need to be pre-sold through Quirky’s online store before they can really go the distance and actually manufacture the product. In theory, the Quirky community will help pre-sell the product by telling their friends what a cool product it is and basically conducting word-of-mouth marketing. In other words, they will evangelize your product.
Six. If enough products are pre-sold–that is, if the threshold amount predetermined by Quirky is met–your product will be manufactured and will be made available for sale.
Seven.What do you get from all of this? If your product is manufactured you get 12 cents out of every dollar your product earns. (And remember, the only money that you pay throughout this entire process are the $99.00 that you paid in the beginning when you submitted your idea.)
Eight. The members of the Quirky community that participated throughout the whole development process get 18 cents out of every dollar your product earns distributed among them. In other words, even if you don’t have a product idea you can contribute with comments and suggestions to the development of all the products that are currently in the pipeline at Quirky and maybe even make some money from your contribution.
Here’s An Example: Sukido
Avi Goldfinger submitted the following idea to Quirky, Inc.: A game called “Sukido” which is basically based on the popular sudoku game, except it’s for kids. It uses large, colorful game pieces instead of numbers to make it more appealing to children. (Avi’s product was already pretty developed when he submitted it to Quirky, Inc.; some people simply submit doodles of their product, or even just a written description, which is fine.)
In the comments section over at “Quirky” you’ll notice people expanding on the idea and making it better with suggestions such as the following:
- On the back of the blocks have the numbers written on them. This way kids could choose to play with the “numbers” side up when they’re ready.
- Change the name to “Kidoku”.
- Add magnets to the pieces so kids can play with the game in the car or on plane trips.
- Sell replacement pieces to cover missing pieces.
- Have a web site so that parents can download tiles with new, more difficult puzzles on them.
As you can see from the comments, the Quirky community provides useful feedback.
What If Your Idea Is Not Selected?
If your idea doesn’t get chosen–that is, it isn’t validated–then you retain the rights to your idea. Did you just lose $99.00? The Quirky team argues that you don’t lose your money because you get the following:
In-depth, real-time idea evaluation from the Quirky community, and a demographic profile of those who supported your idea and of those who did not. In other words, you now have more information with which to make the decision whether or not to proceed with your idea on your own.
Conclusion
This article is not meant to be an endorsement of Quirky, Inc. It’s meant to showcase an interesting, new business model–Quirky, Inc. was just launched last month–, to give you something to consider if you have an idea you would like to see developed and are unsure of how to proceed, and to direct you toward a site where you can see first-hand what the product development process looks like.
In addition, Quirky, Inc. is an interesting application of social networking: it’s product development through social networking.
The blog “TechCrunch” published an article about Quirky, Inc. on June 1st titled “Quirky Is A Social Network For Product Development”, and a heated discussion took place in the comments sections (with Ben Kaufman making an appearance). Some people say in the comments that it’s a great idea, and others say it’s just stupid to pay $99.00 to give your ideas away.
Some things to consider:
- Are you paying $99.00 to give your ideas away?
- A brilliant idea that is not executed is worthless.
- Product developers could be watching the Quirky, Inc. web site waiting to snag good ideas.
- If your product does not get chosen, is it worth it to pay $99.00 for getting community feedback in real time about your product and market data on who liked your idea and who didn’t?
- Is a 12% return on investment for your idea good (in fact, it’s more than a 12% ROI because the only money you put down is the submission fee)?
- Would you be better off developing your idea on your own?
So, what do you think? Is Quirky, Inc. a good idea? Watch the YouTube Video below (50 seconds) and let me know what you think in the comments section.
Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe for free by RSS or e-mail and you’ll always know when I publish something new. (What’s RSS?). Also, please share it on the social media site of your choice.
I Recommend:
My ebook “How to Be More Creative – A Handbook for Alchemists” explains that creativity is not the sole domain of the arts but is important in any field. Whatever you do, creativity helps you do it better. Discover practical advice on how to be more creative in every life endeavor by reading my ebook.
The Sedona Method is a simple, powerful, easy-to-learn technique that shows you how to let go of any negative, unwanted or painful feelings you may be experiencing at any particular moment. It consists of a series of questions you ask yourself that lead your awareness to focus on what you’re feeling in the moment and gently guide you toward letting it go. Read my review of the Sedona Method here.










{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }
I think Quirky sounds like a good program for people who have great ideas for products but no viable means to build prototypes, test the product, market, and sell the product. However, I could see where serious inventors might stay away (who wants to lose the rights to their idea?) but for people without a way to launch their product idea, it could be a useful tool. Thanks for sharing this!
Melissa Donovans last blog post..What is Creative Writing?
Hi Melissa: I agree. If you have an idea on how to solve a small problem people might have–for example, how to get children to learn to put on the right shoe on the right foot (a woman invented a sticker set for this)–and you don’t have any product development expertise, Quirky could be the solution. I think a lot of people have ideas that could potentially be turned into products but they find the whole process of product design, creating a logo, packaging, finding someone to manufacture the product, and so on to be too overwhelming. And if your product does well, getting 12 cents for every dollar earned is not bad at all.
“it’s just stupid to pay $99.00 to give your ideas away.” I have to admit this is my initial reaction. I’ll take a closer look at the website, maybe I’ll change my mind.
Vered – MomGrinds last blog post..10 Ways To Love Yourself As A Woman
Hi Vered: I think a lot of ideas are lost because people don’t have the time, money, expertise, and so on, to turn their ideas into products. If you have a truly brilliant idea, and are willing to spend the necessary resources to make your idea happen, then Quirky doesn’t make much sense for you. But if the alternative is to never see your product become a reality, then Quirky could be a viable option.
Very interesting – and also a well written report about Quirky. Sounds like a fun place. I’d like to be on their opinion panel!
suzens last blog post..The Golden Halo Twins – Intention and Commitment
Hi Suzen: Thank you. You can head on over to Quirky and sign up, for free, and you can become an influencer just by commenting on other people’s ideas.
I think this is a brilliant idea – although I’ve none to offer to Quirky. It seems like it’s a good learning experience especially if you have several ideas – you may be able to submit one, make 12% (if everything goes as you’d hope), learn, and then execute/develop the others on your own. I’m going to head over now and check it out. Thanks!
Laurie | Express Yourself to Successs last blog post..Body Language Communicates
Hi Laurie: As soon as I came across it I thought, “this looks really interesting”. I’m going to keep my eye on Quirky and see how it develops (it’s brand new).
That’s a cool concept for a company. $99 isn’t too steep of a price or too little. I like that they have a reasonable barrier to entry.
I always have ideas that I think would be great, but never get any feedback on them. I know most of them are lousy, but maybe one of them might be a hit. If I submit to Quirky I might get a better idea if they could really work or not.
Karl Staib – Work Happy Nows last blog post..How to Build Confidence at Work
Hi Karl: It is a reasonable barrier to entry because without it you’d probably get people submitting the first thing that pops into their head, and that’s just a waste of everybody’s time. I also think that just by hanging around Quirky you can start to get a better of feel for what’s a good product idea and what isn’t, and possibly get your creative juices going.
Thanks for this fascinating tip, Mare. I’ll check out their site, right after commenting here.
I’m a small biz owner who can’t stop reinventing himself and his products. And I have lost thousands of dollars that way. Serious marketing research is something most entrepreneurs can’t afford. Quirky’s approach looks like a very viable solution to me. Considering that the major investment often begins once you’ve reached a higher level – $99 bucks is nothing!
My example: I created Agasweet flavored agave nectar. My local accounts supported me well, for a while. Then, Whole Foods Market and other huge retailers expressed their interest. I thought I had it made. However – hiring a production and marketing company, and dealing with large (and mean) distributors, nearly bankrupted me. I couldn’t finance my expansion any longer and had to license out my business. Now I get 2 percent of the net sales. Where was Quirky when I needed them?
I better grab my box of quirky ideas and head on over there…
Chef Keems last blog post..One Million Free Samples – Single Serve Cups Of Ciao Bella Gelato!
Hi Chef Keem: Thank you for sharing your real life example with us. I know that taking your product from the idea stage to making it a reality is extremely difficult, and it can be very costly as well. There are so many different things to think of, including market research, product design, packaging, marketing, distribution, and so on.
Good luck with your box of quirky ideas. I’m going to be hanging around there and I look forward to seeing your ideas submitted.
Hi Mare .. seems like an excellent idea .. and I think I’ll go over and be an influencer (or mini one) ..
it doesn’t matter if I don’t have a product .. we’ve all got ideas and can learn from others’ creativity and ideas and just think out of the box for our own ideas ..
the word ‘evangelise’ .. I hate! .. but it is so appropriate – and so useful to us in the internet word .. we only need the ‘word of mouth’ promotion & we’re off ..
Thanks for a great resource .. wonderful to know about ..
Hilary Melton-Butcher
Positive Letters
Hilarys last blog post..Plants as metal gatherers – who’d have thought it?
Hi Hilary: I think one of the best ways to come up with your own product is to look at the types of products others are coming up with. That and setting the intent to be more aware of any problem in your environment you’ve been accepting until now but which can actually be resolved. Yeah, there are many ways of saying to “spread through word of mouth”, another one is “to sneeze your idea” which isn’t very pretty either.
Hi Mare,
I think the idea has real potential. And I don’t see the price as too high. My only concern would be if someone might steal my idea, were I to put something out there. I’m not sure if that’s a valid concern or not. The feedback alone that you might get is probably well worth the price of submission.
Lances last blog post..Sunday Thought For The Day
Wow I love it. I’ve several thoughts. Would the pet rock have made it through this process, I wonder? This is a far better deal than the ripoff invention promotion companies. Have you become an influencer Mare? Social media for product development is such a grand idea. There’s a theme there that has me pondering. Thanks!
Tom Volkar / Delightful Works last blog post..Five Disturbing Ways To Make More Money
This is pretty interesting and I’m glad to raed this: “If your idea doesn’t get chosen–that is, it isn’t validated–then you retain the rights to your idea.”
Because an idea not picked up by the community may still be a valuable idea. And it’s nice to know someone can’t just go ahead and run with it. That’s what I gather from this article, at least.
Cool site.
Bamboo Forest – PunIntendeds last blog post..Why You Should Anticipate Things Will Go Well
Thanks for this. My sense is that this site might be useful to me because I tend to have a lot of “throwaway” product or website ideas that I know I will totally lose my focus if I pursue and that I’m only semi-confident in — why not see if someone else is overjoyed by them?
A terrific post. Thought it so good I’ve put a link to it from my own blog. Well done. Well researched.
Anthony James Barnett – authors last blog post..Quirky ideas
Hi Anthony: They have a new product now which is an arm sling which you can decorate. Looks interesting.
Hi Chris: I think Quirky could be a great testing ground for ideas.
Hi Bamboo: You’re right: just because an idea isn’t chosen doesn’t mean it’s a bad idea. Maybe it just needs some more work or needs to be positioned to service a different segment of the population. And yes, people shouldn’t take your idea if it’s not chosen and run with it; it’s still your idea.
Hi Tom: I’m signed up to be an influencer, but I don’t think I’ve racked up any points yet.
Hi Lance: I think there’s always the potential that people might steal your ideas. However, it’s so difficult to get a product to market that I don’t know how may people would take ideas from Quirky and try to implement them on their own.
I found this article to be fairly “quirky”
.-= Quirky Products Guy´s last blog ..The Snap-it Kool =-.
I think it is more suitable for venture capitalists. What guarantee they give about idea privacy and what if idea collides with others?
.-= Rohit Prakash´s last blog ..Why you must stop following the herd? =-.
Hi Rohit: It’s intended for people who have ideas for inexpensive items which would be very difficult for them to develop and bring to market themselves. If you have the funds and knowledge to develop your ideas on your own, then you’re probably best off doing it on your own.
Marelisa,
Great! I am surprised with the social networking ideas we are seeing these days. They have given a different meaning to the Internet.
.-= Rohit Prakash´s last blog ..Why you must stop following the herd? =-.