Four Outstanding Thoughts on Innovation

by Mare on October 2, 2008

(”Power of Innovation”; courtesy of Stephen Elliot)

Although people’s first instincts during an economic downturn are to play it safe and postpone any goals of starting new business ventures, with a little creativity anyone can thrive even amidst a so-called recession.  Below you will find four outstanding thoughts on creativity and innovation to inspire you to act and take full advantage of your most important asset: your mind.

Know That There Are a Gazillion Ideas Out There

Even though the phrase “Everything has already been done” seems to permeate most people’s thinking, the reality is that everything can be improved upon. The American journalist Lincoln Steffens wrote the following in 1931, which remains as true today as it was then:

“Nothing is done.  Everything in the world remains to be done or done over.  The greatest picture is not yet painted, the greatest play isn’t written, the greatest poem is unsung.  There isn’t in all the world a perfect railroad, nor a good government, nor a sound law.  Physics, mathematics, and especially the most advanced and exact of the sciences are being fundamentally revised.  Chemistry is just becoming a science; psychology, economics, and sociology are awaiting a Darwin, whose work in turn is awaiting an Einstein . . . “

Jump to the Next Curve

Guy Kawasaki–a well-known venture capitalist who started out working for Steve Jobs–gave the keynote presentation at the 2007 Event Marketing Conference. In his presentation–entitled “The Art of Innovation”–Guy explains that there are many companies that compete with each other on the same curve. If they were daisy wheel printer companies, they think innovation means adding Helvetica in 24 points. Instead, they should be jumping to the next curve: laser printing. (You can see a slideshow of the presentation here).  Some examples of jumping to the next curve are the following:

In his post “Random Travel Thoughts” Seth Godin asks: “Why doesn’t the airport have sleeping benches?”

Yotel did him one better: At the Gatwick and Heathrow airports in London you can book a cabin inside the airport terminal buildings, just a short walk away from the departure gates. The capsule-hotel’s cabins are, as described on tripadvisor.com by a guest, “just like a space-age train cabin”.

Innovation

Small but not cramped, premium rooms feature a comfortable, handmade bed that slides down to full size, a bathroom with a ‘monsoon’ shower, and a small desk. The cabins are available for short-term hire and passengers in transit can have a shower, take a nap and get some work done without leaving the terminal.

In my blog post, “Thoughts to Get Your Creative Juices Flowing” I included a photograph of The Washing Machine/Toilet which stores water after each washing cycle, which is then used to flush the toilet below it. This is another example of jumping to the next curve.

Innovation

The elliptiGO glide bike offers riders the best elements of running and cycling in one machine. Although running provides a great cardiovascular workout and improves general fitness, many runners are plagued with back and knee injuries due to the high impact nature of the sport. Similarly, bike riders often suffer from shoulder and back injuries and saddle-soreness.

When you ride the elliptiGO you use the same biomechanics of running but the impact is reduced and the upright position is a much more comfortable way to ride a bike. Plus, users of the elliptiGO get the added benefit of the speed and feel of a bike ride. Again, this wasn’t an improvement of the seat of the bike to make it more comfortable or making the handlebars longer to lessen the strain on the back, it’s a completely different product.

An example of a company that tried to move further up the curve–through continuous improvements–when it was time to jump to the next curve is Motorola. Continuous improvement will reach a point of diminishing returns; Motorola made the mistake of trying to stay on the same curve instead of jumping to the next one by insisting on improving analog cellular phones after the market had shifted to digital technology.

Don’t Let The Bozo’s Grind You Down

Guy also explains during his “The Art of Innovation” speech that bozos come in many shapes and sizes, and the hardest ones to spot are the ones that have all of the indicators of success: they’re respected in their field and they’re rich, famous, and powerful.  To illustrate Guy’s point, here are a few famous examples of brilliant ideas that were originally turned down:

  • When Fred Smith turned in a paper proposing reliable overnight service delivery, his Yale University management professor responded as follows: “The concept is interesting and well-formed, but in order to earn better than a ‘C,’ the idea must be feasible.”  Smith went on to found Federal Express Corp.
  • Thomas J Watson, President of IBM, is reported to have said: “I think there is a world market for maybe five computers”. In a similar vein, Ken Olsen, co-founder of Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC) , is quoted as saying: “There is no reason why anyone would want a computer in their home.”
  • An 1873 Western Union internal memo said the following: “This telephone has too many shortcomings to be seriously considered as a means of communication.  The device is inherently of no value to us.”
  • This was the initial response that Debbie Fields received to her idea of starting Mrs. Fields’ Cookies: “A cookie store is a bad idea. Besides, the market research reports say America likes crispy cookies, not soft and chewy cookies like you make.”

Welcome Wild Ideas

Judging shuts down idea generation. The physiological reasons for this shutting down is rooted in the brain. In basic terms, the three layers of the brain are the outer layer, which is the neo-cortex; the middle layer, which is the limbic system; and the inner-most layer, which is the brain stem. Each performs a different function. The brain stem focuses on food, fight, flight, and reproduction, that is, survival. It responds immediately to anything it perceives to be a threat, whether physical or psychological. The limbic section governs emotions and feelings. The neo-cortex controls thinking, speaking, and problem solving.

Creativity occurs at the level of the neo-cortext. Because judging is a threat, the brain shifts from the neo-cortex, through the limbic, to the brain stem to assure social-psychological survival. This shift shuts down the creative process. (Source: Add Creativity to Your Decision Processes).

Instead of allowing your inner critic to hold you back from coming up with wild, crazy ideas, know that even the most outlandish ideas can turn into something very practical. An example that is often cited to show how wild ideas can lead to an effective, practical solution is the following: A telephone company had to constantly send out their repair crews to fix telephone wires broken by ice on the lines. The company initiated a creative session to solve the problem and the session was started off with a random word, “bear”. The first idea was completely nuts: train bears to climb the poles and shake the wire.

They brainstormed on how to coax the bears up the telephone poles and someone suggested getting honey to the top of the poles.  But how would they get honey to the top of the poles?  The suggestion was to use helicopters.  Then the group realized that the solution was that the helicopter propellers could shake off the ice. Criticism at the outset would have turned off the process that led to a practical solution.

Conclusion

If you haven’t seen Guy’s “The Art of Innovation” speech, I strongly recommend that you do.  It’s almost an hour long but it’s entertaining and very informative.  In addition, you’ll find three suggestions on excellent creativity books I recommend you read below my signature.


Recommended Reading:

Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe by RSS or e-mail and you’ll always know when I publish something new. If you’d like information on how RSS works, go here. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Share and Enjoy:
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Mixx
  • Reddit
  • Print this article!
  • Netvouz
  • Sphinn
  • Furl

{ 6 trackbacks }

Books and Magazines Blog » Archive » Four Outstanding Thoughts on Innovation
10.02.08 at 3:18 am
Three Incredibly Effective Creativity Techniques | Abundance Blog - Marelisa Online
10.08.08 at 3:05 am
Got It? | Delightful Work
10.16.08 at 2:02 pm
18 Ways to be Uber Creative | Abundance Blog - Marelisa Online
10.23.08 at 11:16 pm
The Secret of Unbridled Creativity
11.07.08 at 2:54 am
30 Creativity Cards: A Gift I Made For You
11.21.08 at 10:16 am

{ 30 comments… read them below or add one }

Cath Lawson 10.02.08 at 3:12 am

Hi Mare - this is interesting stuff. I completely agree - there’s far more to be invented and improved.

I like the idea of the washing machine toilet. And I didn’t know about Yotel but I’ll be checking it out next time I fly via London.

M 10.02.08 at 7:39 am

So much insight! Thank you for the fantastic read!

“Never be afraid to try something new. Remember, amateurs built the ark. Professionals built the Titanic. “

Ms last blog post..Kindness

Harmony 10.02.08 at 11:32 am

Marelisa,
Thanks AGAIN, your posts are excellent and so resourceful.
One area I focus on with clients is ALLOWING this kind of creativity. It is a big challenge to allow people to share wacky ideas without censoring or judging them before they have chance to take more logical form.
Like your example of Mrs F. cookies…status quo suits the mind - only the bigger mind is ready to soar, and that takes training to give it room.

Vered - MomGrind 10.02.08 at 12:54 pm

Interesting info on how the brain handles creativity and judging. It’s especially interesting that a lot of the criticism comes from within.

Writer Dad 10.02.08 at 1:21 pm

I’m unsure of the exact date, but in the late 1800’s, the U.S. patent office was considering closing, because they said everything had already been invented. Wow, right?

Hunter Nuttall 10.02.08 at 3:38 pm

@ Writer Dad, I really like that quote, but unfortunately, it appears to be an urban legend.

They say that the Chevy Nova didn’t sell well in Spanish-speaking countries because “no va” means “doesn’t go” in Spanish. Only if you ask any Spanish-speaking person, they’ll say they wouldn’t have interpreted “Nova” that way. The story carries an important lesson, even if it happens to not be true.

I use the “everything that can be invented has been invented” quote sometimes to make a point, but then I whisper the disclaimer that it was made up! I sure wish it were real though. I guess you could say it, and then I could quote you!

Hunter Nuttalls last blog post..How To Realistically Get 500+ Blog Subscribers

Mare 10.02.08 at 6:45 pm

Hi Cath: Isn’t Yotel just the best idea? When I was in college my father lived in Egypt and we would meet somewhere in Europe for breaks. I would have to travel from Washington, DC to New York, then fly to London, and then from London to whatever country my father was waiting for me in. By the time I got to London I felt like roadkill. I would certainly have preferred to wait in one of the yotel cabins (take a shower, take a short nap) instead of sitting in the terminal for six or seven hours.

Mare 10.02.08 at 7:24 pm

Hi Mark : I love that quote. It’s important not top dismiss other people, or dismiss yourself, just because they don’t have the outer indicators of success.

Hi Harmony: I think people who have a reputation for being very smart and/or have a lot of advanced degrees are especially prone to prevent themselves from having whacky ideas. We have to remember that the best minds in history have had tons of whacky–and even downright awful–ideas, which is what allowed them to also have great ideas.

Hi Vered: I thought it was interesting when I read it as well. Knowing that there’s a physiological response when we judge can help us become more tolerating and accepting.

Mare 10.02.08 at 7:28 pm

Hi Writer Dad: Imagine what our life would be like right now if people had dropped all creativity and ingenuity in the 1800’s!

Hi Hunter: It may be an urban legend, but I agree that it helps to make a point. I have heard about Chevy Nova before, and you’re right that I wouldn’t necessarily make the connection right away that it means it doesn’t work (and Spanish is my first language).

Lance 10.02.08 at 9:41 pm

I love that word “gazillion”! It screams infinite to me. What I take away from here is that we can look at anything - and improve it. The washing machine/toilet combo is a great example of this…

Lances last blog post..A Helping Hand

Evelyn Lim 10.02.08 at 10:08 pm

Thanks for the inspiring stories! A clear reminder to me to never laugh or thumb down any of my kids’ weird ideas. I may never know. One of them may turn out to be the next billion dollar idea! Hang on a minute…do I sound like I’m dreaming here…LOL!?!

Evelyn Lims last blog post..How Would You Cross The River?

Mare 10.02.08 at 10:44 pm

Hi Rita: You married an inventor, that’s great. I love shows like “American Inventor”; although some people show up with some pretty nutty things, there are plenty of others with fabulous ideas. Computers definitely have their pros and cons. You’re always very encouraging Rita, thank you.

Hi Lance: I truly believe there’s infinite possibility out there, we just have to set the intent to find great ideas and be willing to invest the hard work it takes to turn ideas into reality.

Hi Evelyn: I was reading a paper called “The Plural of Leaf is Tree” which highlights how schools squelch creativity and tend to reward students who simply regurgitate what the teacher says and punish those who think out of the box. And who knows, maybe your kids’ whacky ideas will help the world in some great way in the future :-)

Bamboo Forest 10.03.08 at 12:26 am

The capsule-hotel’s are a really cool idea and a perfect example of ingenuity.

Bamboo Forests last blog post..7 Things That Happen in Movies - But Probably Not to You

Mitch 10.03.08 at 12:58 am

My goodness, what a wonderful post! I love the idea of the little rooms at Heathrow Airport, and I’ve been in enough airports to know that I might even think about popping out $100 just to have that kind of comfort for a few hours. Then again, I’d also take the sleeping benches, but can you imagine how big the airports would have to be then? :-) Great job!

Mitchs last blog post..Uneasy Lies The Head,…

Robin 10.03.08 at 2:47 am

Hi Mare - I think its so true - the ideas are there for the taking. We just need to know how to access them - which many of us are doing, in our own way. See you!

Robins last blog post..Ice And Global Warming

MizFit 10.03.08 at 6:07 am

AMEN, Sister!

especially on the BOZOS!

MizFits last blog post..Im down with MBT (yeah you know me)

Stacey / Create a Balance 10.03.08 at 8:51 am

I have a “jump to the next curve” idea that is waiting to be created. My “block” is the lack of money and IT know-how to build what I need to build. In the meantime, I’m still building this idea in my head (and some on paper) for when the right opportunity knocks!

Stacey / Create a Balances last blog post..Yes, Oprah Really Did Call Me

Chris 10.03.08 at 3:18 pm

I got a lot of ideas anyone one to take a risk and fund my crazy thoughts?

I’m a big fan of Guy Kawasaki.

Chriss last blog post..GUT CHECK!

Ricardo Bueno 10.03.08 at 3:44 pm

Re: “Don’t Let Bozos Grind You Down!”

This is a very, VERY important point! You can’t let people hold you back, push you down, or kick you off track with all the progress you’re making. Associate yourself with those who support your goals, your dreams, your desires. Ever heard the saying, “you are the company you keep?” Well, don’t associate yourself with negativity because it really isn’t constructive. It will ruin any progress that you’re making.

Mare 10.03.08 at 9:29 pm

Hi Bamboo: I’m just in awe of that capsule hotel. Our airport here is referred to as the Hub of the Americas since Panama has such a centric location. I wonder if something like that would work here.

Hi Mitch: I know what you mean about airports, I’ve been in quite a few of them myself. I’ve heard that they have beds in airplanes now if you fly first class. That sounds like something I’d like to experience as well (as opposed to sitting for 8 hours).

Hi Robin: I also think that ideas are everywhere, begging to be brought down to reality :-)

Hi MizFit: Down with the Bozos! :-)

Hi Stacey: Just hold the intent to make the idea a reality and keep your eyes open, what you want also wants you.

Hi Chris: Creators have to pour sweat and tears into their ideas!

Hi Ricardo: You have to build a fence around your dream and be very careful about who you invite into your garden. When your dreams are just seedlings they can be easily trampled, whether by people who are jealous that your idea is taking root, or people who genuinely think that they’re trying to help but were simply not able to grasp the idea you’re developing.

Barbara Swafford 10.04.08 at 3:41 am

Hi Marelisa - What a timely post. As you said, with the downturn of the economy many think they don’t stand a chance. You’re right, there are a gazillion ideas out there. We just have to open our minds and let the creative juices flow.

Barbara Swaffords last blog post..Just A Click Away - Open Mic

Tom Volkar / Delighful Work 10.04.08 at 6:47 am

Hi Mare, You’ve stimulated my brain. Just when I was reading about the glide bike I had this flash of wonderment. Now I have this burning desire to ponder what the next curve in career coaching is. A top notch article will do that - make you look at your own situation and follow-up on your inspirations. Very Good I’ve Stumbled it!

Tom Volkar / Delighful Works last blog post..Why Don’t We Use What We Already Know?

Stacey Shipman 10.04.08 at 9:32 am

I agree with some others - the “Bozo’s” can often become the block for many people. It’s so easy to get stuck if faced with questions like “what are you doing that for?” and “How will you make money doing that?”

In that case I think it’s important to listen to your gut. If you’re confident with the idea, go for it! You never know unless you give it a try.

Davina 10.04.08 at 11:46 am

Yotel’s airport cabins are a fantastic idea. I chuckled at Ken Olsen’s statement, “There is no reason why anyone would want a computer in their home.” We showed him!

Davinas last blog post..Creative Luny Landing In The Sand

Al at 7P 10.04.08 at 3:17 pm

Hi Mare - agreed, truly great innovations are recession-proof. I really like that quote from Lincoln Steffens too!

I always find new stuff with your posts, too. I never heard of the elliptiGO before!

Ricardo Bueno 10.04.08 at 4:23 pm

Ok, I LOVE the ANALOGY you gave just then in your response to me! It’s so incredibly true… You have to be very careful of who you surround yourself with to support the growth of your dream.

Melissa Donovan 10.05.08 at 2:14 am

It just goes to show that sometimes the best ideas are the ones that sound the craziest at the time and true innovators are also risk takers. Interesting stuff.

Melissa Donovans last blog post..Book Lovers’ Special

Mare 10.05.08 at 10:02 am

Hi Barbara: Whenever I read about people who made it big, lose everything, and then rebuild, I think: there’s someone who understands that what they truly need in life is already inside of them.

Hi Tom: I’ll look forward to reading on your blog what the next curve in life coaching is :-)

Hi Stacey: I think we also have to be careful not to be our own bozo. Kawakazi explains that he was asked to join Google when it had just started and he declined because he wasn’t able to visualize would it would become. He could easily be worth about $2 billion today if he had joined Google.

Hi Davina: I am just in complete awe of Yotel. It’s one of the things that you ask yourself, why didn’t anyone think of this before?

Hi Al: The elliptigo is hot of the presses. Remember you saw it here first :-)

Mare 10.05.08 at 10:04 am

Hi Ricardo: Unfortunately I’ve had experience with letting the wrong people into my garden. I’ve also been fortunate enough to have some really good people help me out, so it’s vital to be wise about who you let in.

Hi Melissa: I think a lot of people don’t like the word “risk”, but anything new is risky.

Mare 10.18.08 at 10:13 am

@Writer Dad: I found this quote:

“Everything that can be invented has been invented.” Charles Duell, U.S. Office of Patents Commissioner, 1899 (apocryphal)

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Copyright © 2008 "Marelisa-Online"; All Worldwide Rights Reserved.